Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill | Authentic Mediterranean Cuisine in Dyer, IN

Overview

Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill, nestled on Joliet Street in Dyer, Indiana, offers a genuine taste of the Mediterranean right in the heart of the Midwest. This modest yet inviting restaurant specializes in authentic Middle Eastern dishes that resonate with freshness, bold flavors, and heartfelt care in every bite.

The core of Mt. Olive lies in its expertly crafted shawarma and gyro platters. Whether you choose the beef or chicken shawarma or the perfectly seasoned gyro, each dish delivers a satisfying blend of spices and tenderness. For those seeking something more robust, the Mixed Grill platter or the skewers—ranging from kofta to filet mignon—are grilled to perfection, boasting a beautiful char that locks in juicy, tender meat.

Complementing the mains, the Mezza and sides like Baba Ghanouj, Labneh, and Mediterranean Hummus provide fresh, vibrant flavors that enhance the meal experience. Notably, their falafels have won over even the skeptics, turning a simple appetizer into a standout dish that many customers now crave.

The dining space accommodates a cozy crowd with its four booths, creating a warm and intimate atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. The small but comfortable setting invites families, friends, and solo diners alike to enjoy a relaxed yet flavorful meal. While the space is limited, the carry-out service thrives, ensuring that locals can bring a piece of Mt. Olive’s Mediterranean charm back to their tables.

A defining highlight of Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill is the personalized and attentive service led by Alex, the owner. Guests consistently share how welcome and cared for they feel, recounting moments of genuine hospitality and kindness that go well beyond typical restaurant experiences. This human connection enriches the culinary journey, making each visit memorable on both a taste and emotional level.

Mt. Olive Mediterranean Grill stands out as a remarkable destination for those craving authentic, homemade Mediterranean cuisine paired with heartfelt service. Its balance of quality food, cozy environment, and personable staff makes it a cherished spot in the Dyer community—perfect for anyone who appreciates honest flavors served with warmth and respect.

What Customers Say

Victoria Gomez

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Authentic Middle eastern food! Chicken shawarma was flavorful! Filet mignon skewer was cooked perfect! Nice char on the outside but super soft on the inside. Must try their falafels; never liked the dish until I had theirs today! Only place I’ll be eating falafel from now on. I highly recommend giving them a try!

Kayla Miller

Dec 3,2025

5/5

We’ve been searching for new places to eat at and they did not disappoint! Everything was so beyond tasty! We’ve been to a couple Mediterranean places in the area and this one is our new fav! We did not leave one drop of anything on our plates. The staff were very helpful with helping us pick out our food as well & the service was fast. Will definitely be coming back to try other items & highly recommend

Thomas Johnson

Dec 3,2025

5/5

Everything was fresh and cooked to order. We got falafel appetizers which were amazing. The gyro meat was seasoned so well, I haven't had gyro meat that tasted that great! Super nice people, very attentive! Looking forward to going back to get the chicken shawarma which seems to be a very popular item to order there. There have 4 booths for dining in. Their carry out business is quite busy!

Leann Musleh

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I had such an incredible experience here! The owner was unbelievably kind and went above and beyond, he even added extra food items for me to try, which was such a sweet surprise. The customer service alone deserves five stars, but the food made it even better. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and honestly some of the best I’ve had in a while. You can really tell they care about quality and making sure customers leave happy. I’ll definitely be coming back! Highly recommend.

Fatima Trujillo

Dec 3,2025

5/5

If you’re looking for authentic Mediterranean food with a homemade touch, this is the place to go! Although the restaurant is small, it’s comfortable enough to make you feel right at home. It has a warm, family-friendly atmosphere, and the owner, Alex, is truly an exceptional person. He welcomed us and treated us as if we were guests in his own home. The food is fresh, flavorful, and prepared with care—definitely the kind of meal that makes you want to come back. We even found out it was Alex’s birthday on the day we visited! I’m especially grateful for the soup he offered to prepare for my husband after learning he was in the hospital. May God bless the work of his hands! Highly recommended!

Desiree

Dec 3,2025

5/5

This is a small restaurant with a few seating area. Our big family came in hungry and boy did they deliver. They were short staffed when we came but Alex, took good care of us despite being busy. The food is really good! We got the beef shawarma, chicken shawarma, grilled/charcoal chicken, baba ganoush and falafel (eat while it's warm!!) and all were delicious! Food also came with pickle which were also really good. We would definitely be back and try the other dishes

Sarah no

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I really wanted to leave 5 stars because the food was amazing and the cook was so friendly and brought out nice samples. Everything was very reasonably priced as well After I posted this, the owner replied. That was my goal. The goal was for them to see it and hopefully address the problem of not being able to get free tap water. Because charging for tap water is illegal. I did love the food and I want this business to succeed. I definitely recommend coming here because it is very good and well priced.

Marycela Alejandre

Dec 3,2025

5/5

I’ve visited Mt Olive Mediterranean Grill about five times now, and every single visit has been consistently amazing. The food is always fresh, flavorful, and served in generous portions. Their sauces are incredible—rich, delicious, and the perfect complement to every dish. The falafels deserve a special shoutout: perfectly seasoned, flavorful, and never dry. I also tried their lentil soup recently, and it was absolutely delicious—comforting and full of flavor. On top of the great food, the service is always warm and welcoming. You can really tell they care about quality in both their dishes and their customer experience. Highly recommended for anyone looking for authentic, satisfying Mediterranean food!